Skip to content

January 18, 2023

Ambulatory surgery as a public health policy in Brazil

By Fabrício Galvão

An alternative to reduce the waiting lines for elective procedures.

According to data from the Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística (IBGE), over the last hundred years the life expectancy of Brazilians has increased considerably. In 1920 it was only 33 years of age, reaching more than double that in 2021, with an average of 77 years. Population growth over the last hundred years has also been quite significant. The Brazilian population went from 28 million in 1920 to more than 208 million in 2020, with people over 65 years of age rising from 4% to 10% between 1980 and 2020.

Brazil still presents a wide variation of socioeconomic and geographic realities, taking into account its 26 states and the federal capital. This scenario brings great challenges to public leaders and managers regarding the management of population health. It is common knowledge that public hospitals face serious access problems, often with a shortage of professionals, technology, beds, and operating rooms, which force the population to wait long periods for care, due to the scarcity of supply and the abundance of demand.

A 2018 survey by the Conselho Nacional de Medicina and Datafolha reveals that waiting lines were identified as the main source of dissatisfaction for users of the SUS (Brazilian Unified Health System). At the time, 30% of participants reported having waited for some type of care – more than 12 months.

The concentration of specialists and health professionals in large general hospitals in the more developed urban areas often prevents patients from receiving the necessary care because of difficulties in getting to the place of care (distance and cost). This makes absenteeism (when patients miss their appointments in the SUS) an important cause of wasted resources and prolonged waiting lines, since the resources, especially human ones, allocated to care that is not performed do not materialize the benefit to the population, intensifying the problem.

In addition, there is another factor that contributes to elective surgeries being postponed or not performed: the 10-year lag in the adjustment of the SUS payment schedule. An excerpt from an article by the CFM (Conselho Federal de Medicina), published in November 2022, regarding the absence of readjustments, points out that: "The largest gap, of 17,270%, was found in the payments made for the removal of a semi- or fully-implantable long-term catheter. For at least ten years, the SUS has paid R$ 5.34 per procedure. (…) if the full value indicated in the CBHPM were used, the responsible physician should receive R$ 928 today."

The impact of long waiting lines on public health

The long waiting line for surgery in the public system has a negative impact on the patient's physical health, as their health condition may deteriorate over time. It also negatively impacts their mental health, since it psychologically affects those who wait, indefinitely, for care. In an article in the American Journal of Public Health titled "The Impact of Long Waits for Surgery on Mental Health Outcomes", the authors report that patients who experienced longer waiting times were associated with increased levels of anxiety, depression, and stress. The figure below shows the process from the onset of symptoms to the performance of the surgical procedure, clearly illustrating the main points of delay, especially from the indication of surgery to the performance of the case.

The adoption of integrated solutions that make it possible to meet, in an efficient and cost-effective way, the need for a rapid response to the problems mentioned above is increasingly urgent. In this sense, ambulatory surgery has proven effective as an alternative to reduce the waiting lines for elective surgeries in Brazil.

This surgical modality makes it possible to perform a wide range of procedures in a single day, organized through specific care pathways, from patient selection to the assessment of their biopsychosocial conditions, allowing the patient to return home the same day.

Ambulatory surgery in public health

Ambulatory surgery plays an important role in reducing the waiting time for elective surgeries. According to the president of SOBRACAM (Sociedade Brasileira de Cirurgia Ambulatorial), Dr. Fábio Soares, "Creating the necessary conditions to select cases that can be operated on in ambulatory units represents a significant removal of procedures from public general hospitals, making room for more complex or urgent cases, allowing faster care and reducing the line of patients who wait, in some cases, more than 2 years for a simple surgery, such as cataract surgery, for example."

Ambulatory procedures, in which most of the recovery takes place outside the environment of a general hospital, are also becoming increasingly popular because of their cost and safety advantages. Portugal and the United Kingdom are examples of large-scale use of ambulatory surgery in public health. In 2004, Portugal established the inclusion of surgical patients on a unified, public list, setting a maximum waiting period of 270 days for surgeries to be performed. In the United Kingdom, where the maximum established period is 18 weeks, according to statistics from the local public health service, this deadline is met in 90% of cases.

For SOBRACAM's vice-president of market relations and author of the book Hospital Dia – Um modelo sustentável, the hospital management specialist Newton Quadros, "Whether in the self-management model or in the PPP model, investment in structures geared toward ambulatory surgery should be present on the agendas of the new officeholders.

For two obvious reasons: the reduction of care costs and the improvement of health care for the population. The effects of a national policy aimed at regulating ambulatory surgery would have a strong positive impact on the population's health and on the states' savings of financial resources".

Ambulatory surgical units have lower implementation and operating costs when compared to general hospitals. They occupy more compact areas and rely on highly efficient care pathways, with fewer equipment and staffing needs, without compromising the safety and quality of the care provided.

This attribute allows units to be installed in remote areas, providing care closer to the population, contributing to the decline in the absenteeism mentioned earlier and helping to reduce the lines and the flow of patients, even in the largest urban centers and general hospitals. Mobile units are also a viable alternative, and can be equipped and operated by specific professionals in initiatives involving one or multiple surgical specialties.

Considering that at least 60% of the procedures on the SUS waiting list correspond to cases that could benefit from the use of ambulatory surgical centers, the impact of this initiative is quite positive in the equation of improving access to public health in Brazil.

For the Harvard School of Public Health professor Julio Frenk, the main challenge in health systems is to train people who can develop the strategic vision, technical knowledge, political skills, and ethical orientation to lead the complex processes of formulating and implementing effective policies. For Frenk, "Without leaders, even the best-designed systems will fail".

Public policy and management are fundamental to the functioning of the health system. The emergence of political leaders who foster the implementation of ambulatory surgery as a public health policy will generate legitimate political capital, directly benefiting the population within their area of coverage, playing not only a role in maintaining the current health system, but also a leading role in enabling and sustaining improvements that will raise equity and increase access to quality health care.

Fabricio Galvão is a founding member, market director, and president-elect for the 2024–2026 term of the Sociedade Brasileira de Cirurgia Ambulatorial (SOBRACAM), Brazilian delegate of the International Association for Ambulatory Surgery (IAAS), entrepreneur, and investor in the health sector.

References

  1. Dobram queixas por tempo de espera. Conselho Federal de Medicina. Datafolha. 2018. Available at: https://portal.cfm.org.br/noticias/pesquisa-cfmdatafolha-dobram-queixas-por-tempo-de-espera/
  2. Defasagem em valores pagos é de até 17 mil %. Conselho Federal de Medicina. 2022. Available at: https://portal.cfm.org.br/noticias/defasagem-em-valores-pagos-e-de-ate-17-mil/
  3. Reichert A, Jacobs R. The impact of waiting time on patient outcomes: Evidence from early intervention in psychosis services in England. Health Econ. 2018 Nov;27(11):1772-1787.
  4. SOBRACAM – Sociedade Brasileira de Cirurgia Ambulatorial – https://www.sobracam.com.br – accessed on January 10, 2023.
  5. Sarmento Junior, Krishnamurti Matos de Araujo, Tomita, Shiro and Kos, Arthur Octavio de Avila. O problema da fila de espera para cirurgias otorrinolaringológicas em serviços públicos. Revista Brasileira de Otorrinolaringologia. 2005, v. 71, n. 3, pp. 256-262. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1590/S0034-72992005000300001
  6. Quadros, N., et al. Hospital Dia – Um Modelo Sustentável – Ed. Dulcina, 2013.
  7. Frenk J. The Global Health System: Strengthening National Health Systems as the Next Step for Global Progress, 2010. PLoS Med 7(1).

Fabrício Galvão

Share

Read also

Your privacy

We use necessary cookies for the website to work, such as those that keep you signed in and remember your language. With your permission, we also measure how the website is used in aggregate, without cookies and on our own server, to improve it. Cloudflare, which protects the website, also measures visits and page load times without cookies and without identifying you; this does not depend on your choice here. You can change your choice at any time under Cookie preferences, in the footer. Read the Cookie Policy